I'm one of the people that thinks that Schotty gets far too much blame when things go wrong. I also think he still makes some bizarre play calls, but overall things have been going well.
One thing I have noticed in his favor. The number of plays the Jets have had over the last few weeks where one (or more!) players are wide open on the field. I've never seen so many plays where guys get open like that downfield and in the endzone.
That is as telling as everything else he does. Yes, he has his tendencies, he doesn't seem to let the RBs get into a rhythm sometimes, and he often goes into shotgun on 3rd and short (a big pet peeve of mine). But, the offense is clicking and he deserves some credit for that.