Originally Posted by 21st Amendment
Take another look at Edmonds numbers. They are pretty damn good. Especially for a good who was an elite CFer.
I did yesterday. He's going to be very close. Would have a better case if he had more than 1 top 5 MVP years, but his power + his defense will definately get him some votes.
It's funny, I would not put in Andy, who has all the rings, but i would put in Mussina. Mussina was a better pitcher, not his fault he was on the Orioles when the Yankees were winning. Moose pitched well in the playoffs, and also had a superb W/L record.