Originally Posted by Untouchable
I don't put either in the elite class.
Just as I didn't put guys like Phil Sims, Kenny Anderson or Dan Fouts in the same group as Montana, Elway, or Marino back in the 80's.
Roethlisberger and Eli are in the next tier. The "very good" tier.
Eli statistically is in that tier though.
Ben is a different type of animal altogether.