Originally Posted by C Mart
For those that use the "terrible hire, dolphins picks sux, talent sux"...He hasn't been the final decision maker...Again, his scouting reports could be 100% accurate but if the decision makers (Ireland, HC) go with who they want how is that Gaine's fault? Or if the coaching staff sux at developing the players that not the scouts fault
It's his fault by not being persuasive. You're not any good at your job if you can't convince people to follow your advice. The only thing that matters is results. Who knows if his untaken advice was any good? You can't go by what somebody supposedly said and was ignored.