Originally Posted by kennyo7
Can you name me one successful team that was built around a Cornerback?
Great teams are generally built around a QB or Stand Out Pass Rusher and to a lesser degree a great RB. Not a CB.
Having a HOF/Top 3 All time CB on a 6-10 team is a luxury not a necessity. Its a bigger luxury when you consider that the Secondary was quite good even without him.
Sorry, there is no rational reason to give in to Revis' demands and resign him. Emotional reasons? Absolutely.
Here is my rationale. When Revis is gone and our Defense becomes pedestrian there will literally be nothing exceptional about the Jets team. We got through the Revis injury this season due to solid play from Landry and Bell. They likely wont be back this season. Trading Revis triggers an additional 3 million cap hit virtually assuring that we will not be able to resign Landry. Our secondary will go from the teams primary strength to a weakness.
If your theory is blow it up and start from scratch and you are hoping for a 3 win season and a shot at a tow 3 pick next season then trading Revis is the move. I think that is a massively high risk move that has a high likelyhood of backfiring. If we end up squeaking out 6 wins we will miss out on the 2 QB's everyone wants and could end up having tanked a season for a bust player like Gholston. As fans we are not privvy to all the details and demands that happen with players and their contracts behind the scenes. There is information that we just don't know. If Revis can be retained for somewhere close to or slightly over Aso's money it is a no brainer to keep him. $13.5 million or so average should get a deal done. I do not subscribe to the throwaway season cult. Football just doesnt work that way. Teams that suck tend to suck for multiple years (see Jags, Bills, Rams, Miami, etc). In football teams need to rebuild on the fly. I also contend that we are not in cap hell. The bad contracts for Sanchez, Holmes and Harris are mitigated starting in 2014. Plenty of cap space to go around at that point. We have the room to pay Revis and still retain our guys and sign FA's moving forward. I trade Cro, get his 9 Million per off the books including 7Million in additional cap space for 2013. I then use that cap space to retain Landry and Pay for my Matt Flynn trade. That alongside the draft and cheap FA's gives us a squad with potential in 2013 plus tons of flexibility in 2014 to change course Flynn doesn't pan out. Low risk and high reward is the way to go.
EDIT - here is the caveat, if Revis thinks that he is the best player in football and deserves an 18Million per type salary then I'd be happy to get rid of him. Thats the thing. None of us really know what it will take to sign the guy. For me he is worth up to 14Million per.