Originally Posted by Beerfish
You want to trade Revis + our 9th pick overall to go up to one to get a QB and take that chance? Have at it. Geno is not Andrew Luck or RG3 or any semblance of that caliber of QB. It's surprising you are taking this tact when you have been all over taking the og at 9 instead of a Qb at 9 that could turn out to be a respectable top 15 QB.
I'm not against trading Revis for a #1 and a #3. I'm against trading Revis and gambling on a pick, like Geno Smith. He's a gamble.
If you told me we're picking the next JJ Watt, it's a no brainer.
If you're telling me we're picking a possible RG3, maybe, not so sure, perhaps, but not probably, then forget it. Take the 1 year rental, and move on. We're getting a #3 anyway if he walks.