First-year HOF candidates - Page 3 - Jets Insider.com Forums

Squirt · 09-29-2011, 08:17 PM

[QUOTE=escamoter2;4165677]First-Year Hall Candidates

[U]Tiki Barber[/U], RB N.Y. Giants, 1997-06
[U]Drew Bledsoe[/U], QB New England, 1993-01; Buffalo 2002-04; Dallas, 2005-06
[U]Bill Cowher[/U], coach Pittsburgh, 1992-06
[U]Stephen Davis[/U], RB Washington, 1996-02; Carolina, 2003-05; St. Louis, 2006
[U]Keyshawn Johnson[/U], WR N.Y. Jets, 1996-99; Tampa Bay, 2000-03; Dallas, 2004-05; Carolina, 2006
[U]Bill Parcells[/U], coach N.Y. Giants, 1983-90; New England, 1993-96; N.Y. Jets, 1997-99; Dallas, 2003-06
[U]Marty Schottenheimer[/U], coach Cleveland, 1984-88; Kansas City, 1989-98; Washington, 2001; San Diego, 2002-06
[U]Will Shields[/U], G Kansas City, 1993-06
[U]Rod Smith[/U], WR Denver, 1995-06
[U]Troy Vincent[/U], DB Miami, 1992-95; Philadelphia, 1996-03; Buffalo, 2004-06; Washington, 2006
[U]Mike Vanderjagt[/U], PK Indianapolis, 1998-06

I say Parcells is the only one that gets in. Maybe Shields at some point.[/QUOTE]
I can't believe Joe Klecko is snubbed again. He is a lot more deserving than almost every name on this list. This list is a joke!

Xmarco · 09-30-2011, 03:12 AM

This is the [B]First Year Candidates[/B] not the final list
Not sure if either Bill makes it this year
NFL doesn't want HOF coaches coaching it wants everyone to be retired for good. Shield could possible make the final cut but off my head others probably before him. Did Willie Roaf make it yet?

ROPE · 09-30-2011, 05:10 AM

Both Bill's make it. By the way. Ketshawn Johnson's numbers are as good or better than half the receivers in HOF. The only thing lacking is the rings.
Michael Irvin=Keyshawn Johnson in numbers.

EM31 · 09-30-2011, 08:13 AM

[QUOTE=Savage69;4165957]No way Tiki gets in I would vote for Martin over Tiki..:yes:[/QUOTE]
I agree. I do not think either deserves to be in. At least we got beyond that "first ballot HOF lock" nonsense last year.

CleatMarks · 09-30-2011, 10:24 AM

[QUOTE=ROPE;4166377]Both Bill's make it. By the way. Ketshawn Johnson's numbers are as good or better than half the receivers in HOF. The only thing lacking is the rings.
Michael Irvin=Keyshawn Johnson in numbers.[/QUOTE]

Stanley Morgan's numbers are better than Keyshawn's and he's not in. Nothing is a lock.

Jethead · 09-30-2011, 10:37 AM

Curtis Martin is a stone cold lock. Bettis is odds on. Agree with poster who said Parcells has come back one too many times to be voted in yet - need to be really retired. Cowher is way overrated and doesn't belong.

Bearded_Achilles · 09-30-2011, 04:26 PM

[QUOTE=escamoter2;4165677]First-Year Hall Candidates

[U]Tiki Barber[/U], RB N.Y. Giants, 1997-06
[U]Drew Bledsoe[/U], QB New England, 1993-01; Buffalo 2002-04; Dallas, 2005-06
[U]Bill Cowher[/U], coach Pittsburgh, 1992-06
[U]Stephen Davis[/U], RB Washington, 1996-02; Carolina, 2003-05; St. Louis, 2006
[U]Keyshawn Johnson[/U], WR N.Y. Jets, 1996-99; Tampa Bay, 2000-03; Dallas, 2004-05; Carolina, 2006
[U]Bill Parcells[/U], coach N.Y. Giants, 1983-90; New England, 1993-96; N.Y. Jets, 1997-99; Dallas, 2003-06
[U]Marty Schottenheimer[/U], coach Cleveland, 1984-88; Kansas City, 1989-98; Washington, 2001; San Diego, 2002-06
[U]Will Shields[/U], G Kansas City, 1993-06
[U]Rod Smith[/U], WR Denver, 1995-06
[U]Troy Vincent[/U], DB Miami, 1992-95; Philadelphia, 1996-03; Buffalo, 2004-06; Washington, 2006
[U]Mike Vanderjagt[/U], PK Indianapolis, 1998-06

I say Parcells is the only one that gets in. Maybe Shields at some point.[/QUOTE]

First-Ballot:
Bill Cowher, Steelers
Bill Parcells, Giants
Will Shields, Chiefs

Will Get in Eventually:
Marty Schottenheimer, Chiefs
Rod Smith, Broncos

Take them off the list, you're embarassing me:
Tiki Barber, Giants
Drew Bledsoe, Patriots
Stephen Davis, Redskins
Keyshawn Johnson, Bucs
Troy Vincent, Eagles
Mike Vanderjagt, Colts

09-29-2011, 08:17 PM	#41
Squirt Practice Squad Join Date: Feb 2006 Posts: 250	[QUOTE=escamoter2;4165677]First-Year Hall Candidates [U]Tiki Barber[/U], RB N.Y. Giants, 1997-06 [U]Drew Bledsoe[/U], QB New England, 1993-01; Buffalo 2002-04; Dallas, 2005-06 [U]Bill Cowher[/U], coach Pittsburgh, 1992-06 [U]Stephen Davis[/U], RB Washington, 1996-02; Carolina, 2003-05; St. Louis, 2006 [U]Keyshawn Johnson[/U], WR N.Y. Jets, 1996-99; Tampa Bay, 2000-03; Dallas, 2004-05; Carolina, 2006 [U]Bill Parcells[/U], coach N.Y. Giants, 1983-90; New England, 1993-96; N.Y. Jets, 1997-99; Dallas, 2003-06 [U]Marty Schottenheimer[/U], coach Cleveland, 1984-88; Kansas City, 1989-98; Washington, 2001; San Diego, 2002-06 [U]Will Shields[/U], G Kansas City, 1993-06 [U]Rod Smith[/U], WR Denver, 1995-06 [U]Troy Vincent[/U], DB Miami, 1992-95; Philadelphia, 1996-03; Buffalo, 2004-06; Washington, 2006 [U]Mike Vanderjagt[/U], PK Indianapolis, 1998-06 I say Parcells is the only one that gets in. Maybe Shields at some point.[/QUOTE] I can't believe Joe Klecko is snubbed again. He is a lot more deserving than almost every name on this list. This list is a joke!

09-30-2011, 03:12 AM	#42
Xmarco '13 Mission statement:Blow this whole Effin Program up Veteran Join Date: Apr 2004 Posts: 1,726	This is the [B]First Year Candidates[/B] not the final list Not sure if either Bill makes it this year NFL doesn't want HOF coaches coaching it wants everyone to be retired for good. Shield could possible make the final cut but off my head others probably before him. Did Willie Roaf make it yet?

09-30-2011, 05:10 AM	#43
ROPE Detective Jets Insider VIP Join Date: Sep 2011 Posts: 121	Both Bill's make it. By the way. Ketshawn Johnson's numbers are as good or better than half the receivers in HOF. The only thing lacking is the rings. Michael Irvin=Keyshawn Johnson in numbers.

09-30-2011, 08:13 AM	#44
EM31 All Pro Join Date: Sep 2005 Location: Oceanside, Long Island Posts: 9,159	[QUOTE=Savage69;4165957]No way Tiki gets in I would vote for Martin over Tiki..:yes:[/QUOTE] I agree. I do not think either deserves to be in. At least we got beyond that "first ballot HOF lock" nonsense last year.

09-30-2011, 10:24 AM	#45
CleatMarks All League Join Date: Aug 2007 Posts: 2,603	[QUOTE=ROPE;4166377]Both Bill's make it. By the way. Ketshawn Johnson's numbers are as good or better than half the receivers in HOF. The only thing lacking is the rings. Michael Irvin=Keyshawn Johnson in numbers.[/QUOTE] Stanley Morgan's numbers are better than Keyshawn's and he's not in. Nothing is a lock.

09-30-2011, 10:37 AM	#46
Jethead Veteran Join Date: May 2003 Location: Atlanta, GA Posts: 1,264	Curtis Martin is a stone cold lock. Bettis is odds on. Agree with poster who said Parcells has come back one too many times to be voted in yet - need to be really retired. Cowher is way overrated and doesn't belong.

09-30-2011, 04:26 PM	#47
Bearded_Achilles wanna get out of my way?? All Pro Join Date: Dec 2010 Location: Hades Posts: 2,296	[QUOTE=escamoter2;4165677]First-Year Hall Candidates [U]Tiki Barber[/U], RB N.Y. Giants, 1997-06 [U]Drew Bledsoe[/U], QB New England, 1993-01; Buffalo 2002-04; Dallas, 2005-06 [U]Bill Cowher[/U], coach Pittsburgh, 1992-06 [U]Stephen Davis[/U], RB Washington, 1996-02; Carolina, 2003-05; St. Louis, 2006 [U]Keyshawn Johnson[/U], WR N.Y. Jets, 1996-99; Tampa Bay, 2000-03; Dallas, 2004-05; Carolina, 2006 [U]Bill Parcells[/U], coach N.Y. Giants, 1983-90; New England, 1993-96; N.Y. Jets, 1997-99; Dallas, 2003-06 [U]Marty Schottenheimer[/U], coach Cleveland, 1984-88; Kansas City, 1989-98; Washington, 2001; San Diego, 2002-06 [U]Will Shields[/U], G Kansas City, 1993-06 [U]Rod Smith[/U], WR Denver, 1995-06 [U]Troy Vincent[/U], DB Miami, 1992-95; Philadelphia, 1996-03; Buffalo, 2004-06; Washington, 2006 [U]Mike Vanderjagt[/U], PK Indianapolis, 1998-06 I say Parcells is the only one that gets in. Maybe Shields at some point.[/QUOTE] First-Ballot: Bill Cowher, Steelers Bill Parcells, Giants Will Shields, Chiefs Will Get in Eventually: Marty Schottenheimer, Chiefs Rod Smith, Broncos Take them off the list, you're embarassing me: Tiki Barber, Giants Drew Bledsoe, Patriots Stephen Davis, Redskins Keyshawn Johnson, Bucs Troy Vincent, Eagles Mike Vanderjagt, Colts