Peyton Manning.. Greatest

[chirorob]

Regular Season QB of all time.

Even when he got a ring, he did not play well. Once again does not come up big in a big game. His special teams spot him 14 points, still doesn't get it done. I know, the Broncos' safety blew it at the end, but Peytong also had a bunch of chances in OT to win it.

Tim Tebow wins more post season games the Peyton. (I don't even like Tebow)

[Nike]

he declined a post game interview what a frikken cry baby loser.

glad he didnt come to the jets.

[usapaw]

Marino was pretty good at it too..

[rainman]

he's still one of the few best QBs of the Super Bowl era but at this point posterity is likely to favor Brady.

[CleatMarks]

Manning has 8 one and dones. He's tied with Favre with the most playoff losses...

Montana is still the GOAT IMHO.

[Untouchable]

Originally Posted by Nike

glad he didnt come to the jets.

LOL

Yeah, you're definitely GMC.

No one else could be this inept.

[chirorob]

Originally Posted by rainman

he's still one of the few best QBs of the Super Bowl era but at this point posterity is likely to favor Brady.

He's great. In week 1-16. But he seems to come up small in the playoffs. Even games he has won, he hasn't played well.

[Untouchable]

Originally Posted by CleatMarks

Montana is still the GOAT IMHO.

No doubt

And at least in my eyes, I doubt that ever changes.

Still, Peyton is firmly cemented in the Top 5 all-time if you ask me.

[chirorob]

Originally Posted by CleatMarks

Manning has 8 one and dones. He's tied with Favre with the most playoff losses...

Montana is still the GOAT IMHO.

Montana not only never lost a SB, he never even threw a pic in one.

[southparkcpa]

Yeah...Peyton gave up 38 points including a TD with 20 seconds to go.

[Cool as a moose]

He is a different player in the cold on grass and not in a climate controlled dome. I'll take the other manning every time in a big playoff game

[Fixit]

Originally Posted by southparkcpa

Yeah...Peyton gave up 38 points including a TD with 20 seconds to go.

Sure didn't. He did, however, lose a fumble, throw a pick-six, and then throw another pick near the end of OT that B'More converted into a trip to the AFCCG.

[thshadow]

Originally Posted by chirorob

I know, the Broncos' safety blew it at the end

Off topic - but that was the worst play I've ever seen by a safety. Maybe by any defender.

[jetssjumets]

Originally Posted by CleatMarks

Manning has 8 one and dones. He's tied with Favre with the most playoff losses...

Montana is still the GOAT IMHO.

As I said, many times before, P. Manning is one of the all time great chokes! his awful play today lost the game. great my azz.

[King P]

Originally Posted by CleatMarks

Manning has 8 one and dones. He's tied with Favre with the most playoff losses...

Montana is still the GOAT IMHO.

Marino >>> Montana

[DDNYjets]

Originally Posted by Fixit

Sure didn't. He did, however, lose a fumble, throw a pick-six, and then throw another pick near the end of OT that B'More converted into a trip to the AFCCG.

Did you actually see the pick 6 or are you just reading the boxscore?

[Fixit]

Originally Posted by DDNYjets

Did you actually see the pick 6 or are you just reading the boxscore?

Saw it live. Was it completely his fault? No. But when you take into consideration the rest of his postseason resume, that is just what he does.

Was the pick in OT his fault? Because that ended up actually being worse.

[CleatMarks]

Originally Posted by King P

Marino >>> Montana

Only if you value stats. You play for the ring. Montana is GOAT.

[King P]

Originally Posted by CleatMarks

Only if you value stats. You play for the ring. Montana is GOAT.

Rings is a team effort. And Montana had a much better team than Marino.

Montana was the product of a system. Marino was the system

[Mohegangreen]

Originally Posted by thshadow

Off topic - but that was the worst play I've ever seen by a safety. Maybe by any defender.

Reminded me of Jerry Holmes Jan '87