Time for player reviews.

[nyjet4life]

5 is the highest score. Rate these people based on 2004 season.

1. Chad Pennington
2. John Abraham
3. Jason Fabini
4. Reggie Tongue
5. Donnie Abraham
6. Erik Coleman
7. Santana Moss
8. Dwayne Robertson
9. Herm Edwards
10. Donnie Henderson
11. Doug Brien

[ErIcBaRtOn50]

chad 4

abraham (when he played) 5

fabini 3.5

tongue 2

donnie 2.5

erik coleman (for a rookie) 4.5

santana 3.5

drob 4

herm 3

donnie 555555555555555

don't know a doug brien, sorry

[thechadzone10]

1. Chad Pennington ~ 4
2. John Abraham ~ 5
3. Jason Fabini~3
4. Reggie Tongue~1
5. Donnie Abraham ~ 3
6. Erik Coleman~ 4
7. Santana Moss ~ 3.5
8. Dwayne Robertson ~ 5
9. Herm Edwards ~ 4
10. Donnie Henderson~5
11. Doug Brien ~ 3

[Boozer76]

1. Chad Pennington-2.5
2. John Abraham-4 (when he plays)
3. Jason Fabini-3
4. Reggie Tongue-2
5. Donnie Abraham-2
6. Erik Coleman-4
7. Santana Moss-3
8. Dwayne Robertson-4
9. Herm Edwards-3
10. Donnie Henderson-5
11. Doug Brien-3

[Bergen Jet]

1. Chad Pennington 3
2. John Abraham 3.5 (would have been a 5 if he didn't miss so much time)
3. Jason Fabini 3
4. Reggie Tongue 2
5. Donnie Abraham 2.5
6. Erik Coleman 3.5
7. Santana Moss 2.5
8. Dwayne Robertson 4.5
9. Herm Edwards 3
10. Donnie Henderson 5
11. Doug Brien 3

[The Sowell Train]

1. Chad Pennington 3
2. John Abraham 5 When he played
3. Jason Fabini 3
4. Reggie Tongue 2
5. Donnie Abraham 2.5
6. Erik Coleman 3.5
7. Santana Moss 3
8. Dwayne Robertson 4.5
9. Herm Edwards 3
10. Donnie Henderson 5
11. Doug Brien 0

[bitonti]

1. Chad Pennington 4.5
2. John Abraham 3.5
3. Jason Fabini 3.5
4. Reggie Tongue 3
5. Donnie Abraham 3
6. Erik Coleman 3.5
7. Santana Moss 3.5
8. Dwayne Robertson 4.5
9. Herm Edwards 3.5
10. Donnie Henderson 4.5
11. Doug Brien 1

[isired]

i'm going to give 2 grades, reg season / playoffs

1. Chad Pennington: 3.5 / 3 (+.5 on both if you give credit for toughness)
2. John Abraham: 4 / 0 (-.5 on both if you give credit for toughness)
3. Jason Fabini: 3.5 / 2
4. Reggie Tongue: 3.5 / 2.5
5. Donnie Abraham: 3.5 / 3
6. Erik Coleman: 4 / 2.5
7. Santana Moss: 3 / 3
8. Dwayne Robertson: 4 / 4.5
9. Herm Edwards: 3.5 / 2
10. Donnie Henderson: 5 / 6
11. Doug Brien: 3.5 / 1.5
12. Toby Gowin: -5 / -6

[arsenal1189]

cp- 3
abe- 5 (playing)
fabini- 2
tongue- 2.5

d.abe-4
moss- 3
coleman- 3.5
d-rob- 4
edwards- 4
henderson - infinity
brein- 3
gowin- 2.5

[dickkotite]

1. Chad Pennington 5
2. John Abraham 3
3. Jason Fabini 5
4. Reggie Tongue 5
5. Donnie Abraham 6
6. Erik Coleman 9
7. Santana Moss 7
8. Dwayne Robertson 8
9. Herm Edwards 7
10. Donnie Henderson 10
11. Doug Brien 8

[Boozer76]

[quote][i]Originally posted by bitonti[/i]@Jan 25 2005, 07:39 PM
[b] 1. Chad Pennington 4.5
[/b][/quote]
You couldn't possibly keep a straight face while putting a 4.5 out of 5 for Chad, could you?? :blink:

[Bergen Jet]

[quote][i]Originally posted by dickkotite[/i]@Jan 25 2005, 08:17 PM
[b] 1. Chad Pennington 5
2. John Abraham 3
3. Jason Fabini 5
4. Reggie Tongue 5
5. Donnie Abraham 6
6. Erik Coleman 9
7. Santana Moss 7
8. Dwayne Robertson 8
9. Herm Edwards 7
10. Donnie Henderson 10
11. Doug Brien 8 [/b][/quote]
Or, if you are DK you can use a 10 point scale. :lol:

[NYRAGE]

1. Chad Pennington - 2.5
2. John Abraham - 3.5
3. Jason Fabini - 2.5
4. Reggie Tongue - 2
5. Donnie Abraham -2.5
6. Erik Coleman - 3.5
7. Santana Moss - 2
8. Dwayne Robertson - 4
9. Herm Edwards - 2.5
10. Donnie Henderson - 5
11. Doug Brien - 2.5
12. Curtis Martin - 5