Since everyone's bashing Manning (maybe deservedly so, but I don't think the fact that someone lower in the draft is better than you *cough marino'brien* is your fault), my question is:
Would you trade Pennington for Manning, one-for-one if it could be done?
I'm sure Bradway would do it in a second and the giants still love manning, but with fans its a different story. The giants have drunken the kool aid which says the magical number is 35 to see how good he is.
I was talking to a giants fan who now hates manning and says he would do the trade.
As a fan I would like to keep Pennington b/c I really don't like the Mannings and Chad is a great competitor, but as GM you'd have to take Manning - he started the season off well, but sucked late in the season, but if he could keep up his level at the beginning and improve on that he'd be a good QB. Pennington is too risky with injuries to take a shot at over Manning plus his weak arm means the upside potential isn't that great.
My guess is neither of them ever brings a team to a superbowl.