Randy Johnson, no doubt about it. This guy was a big peice of crap. He gave up hr left and right, and had an era over 5. i cant believe the yankees actually traded him and he got signed up to an extension
If you factor in money, I would say A Rod is the biggest bust. He puts up great numbers during the season, but then performs terribly when it counts most. Just my opinion.
How could a guy that the Yankees pay $16M a year for, that has won an MVP and been an extremely productive player, be the biggest bust on the Yankees? Honest question.
And also, Gary Sheffield has been sh*t in the playoffs as a Yankee and did less in his 3 years than A-Rod did in his thus far, so wouldn't he be a bigger bust? Another honest question as I'm really interested in your response to this one. Or did you just forget that Sheff has sucked in the playoffs as a Yankee...
A-Rod has obviously been a dissapointment in the postseason, but you have to take everything into account.
Up to this point, Carl Pavano has been lightyears more of a bust than any other Yankee, excpet maybe Kevin Brown. I give KB some credit for actually pitching through pain, which Mrs. Pavano refuses to do.