Enjoy an Ads-Free Jets Insider - Become a Jets Insider VIP!

View Poll Results: Who would you rather us take spending our first

Voters
52. You may not vote on this poll
  • B. Marshall

    31 59.62%
  • D. Bryant

    21 40.38%
Page 1 of 4 123 ... LastLast
Results 1 to 20 of 65

Thread: Marshall or Bryant

  1. #1
    All Pro
    Join Date
    Sep 2006
    Location
    the 80s
    Posts
    7,766
    Post Thanks / Like

    Marshall or Bryant

    Say we're gonna toss our first pick away to DEN for Marshall.. or trade Gholston or whatever to trade up and take Bryant..


    Ps. don't be a pussie and say "i don't want either". Just tackle the subject at hand.

  2. #2
    Hall Of Fame
    Join Date
    Mar 2007
    Posts
    8,280
    Post Thanks / Like
    Bryant isn't a mistake away from a major suspension so...Bryant.

  3. #3
    All Pro
    Join Date
    Mar 2008
    Location
    Philadelphia
    Posts
    7,077
    Post Thanks / Like
    I'd vote for Marshall just because he's a proven 100 catch a year WR, but he's a freakin headcase. Bryant isn't exactly a model citizen either.

    Not and easy call, but I'll vote for Bryant.

  4. #4
    All Pro
    Join Date
    Sep 2006
    Location
    the 80s
    Posts
    7,766
    Post Thanks / Like
    I'd vote for Bryant in the hopes that under the right tutelage, he'll settle into an elite WR without the baggage. Marshall's baggage isn't going anywhere, but the man's worth the risk if you don't have another option.

  5. #5
    All League
    Join Date
    Aug 2008
    Location
    Boston
    Posts
    3,899
    Post Thanks / Like
    In many cases you HAVE TO choose Marshall because he's done it in this league and is basically uncoverable.

    In the Jets case, Marshall would never last with the contract and suspension issues, so I voted for Dez.

  6. #6
    All Pro
    Join Date
    Aug 2006
    Location
    NYC
    Posts
    5,836
    Post Thanks / Like
    Bryant won't be anything close to what Marshall has been in the league so far. He's nowhere close to being the great RAC receiver, nor has the consistent hands. I don't see him turning into an elite receiver (solid starter, probably). Marshall might come with baggage, but he's so much better than Bryant that he's more worth giving up a 1st rounder for.

  7. #7
    Veteran
    Join Date
    May 2008
    Posts
    1,311
    Post Thanks / Like
    Quote Originally Posted by 49ersJetsfan View Post
    Bryant won't be anything close to what Marshall has been in the league so far. He's nowhere close to being the great RAC receiver, nor has the consistent hands. I don't see him turning into an elite receiver (solid starter, probably). Marshall might come with baggage, but he's so much better than Bryant that he's more worth giving up a 1st rounder for.
    Antonio Bryant?

  8. #8
    Hall Of Fame
    Join Date
    Apr 2003
    Location
    Philly
    Posts
    38,782
    Post Thanks / Like
    i dont like either but forced to choose, Marshall has tape against the NFL, Bryant has tape against the Big 12. no contest the established pro is almost always the safer choice.

  9. #9
    All Pro
    Join Date
    Aug 2006
    Location
    NYC
    Posts
    5,836
    Post Thanks / Like
    Quote Originally Posted by K-Ro 25 View Post
    Antonio Bryant?
    lol if it were Antonio, we'd be talking about a lot more baggage than Marshall brings to the table...

  10. #10
    Rookie
    Join Date
    May 2005
    Posts
    765
    Post Thanks / Like
    I take Bryant. I think he will be the real deal and will come a lot cheaper than Marshall who will want #1 money right away. Bryant will come affordable being a late first round pick. We have too many guys to pay to add a guy like Marshall to the mix. We need to build through the draft here on out this year.

  11. #11
    Hall Of Fame
    Join Date
    Mar 2007
    Posts
    8,280
    Post Thanks / Like
    Quote Originally Posted by 49ersJetsfan View Post
    Bryant won't be anything close to what Marshall has been in the league so far. He's nowhere close to being the great RAC receiver, nor has the consistent hands. I don't see him turning into an elite receiver (solid starter, probably). Marshall might come with baggage, but he's so much better than Bryant that he's more worth giving up a 1st rounder for.
    1. Consistent hands isn't what I think of when I think Brandon Marshall.

    2. Larry Fitzgerald wasn't much of a YAC guy coming out of school either...Bryant's better coming out.

    3. You have to factor in Marshall's proven terrible NFL character with Bryant's rumored NFL character...if we're going to lean on things that are proven.

    4. Also, I think the transition from college to pro WR isn't as bad as it used to be.
    Last edited by SenorGato; 03-31-2010 at 07:27 PM.

  12. #12
    Banned
    Join Date
    Apr 2008
    Location
    NYC
    Posts
    9,157
    Post Thanks / Like
    Bryant is very talented but he's a flake and NFL WR's need to work at their craft to be effective (practice route running, develop chemistry with their QB's etc.). Would rather have Marshall. McDouchebag has lost all his leverage and would maybe settle for a 2nd for Marshall by now.

  13. #13
    All League
    Join Date
    Dec 2008
    Posts
    743
    Post Thanks / Like
    They both seem to be a little bit of a headcase so I take the proven vet, Marshall.

  14. #14
    All Pro
    Join Date
    Jul 2004
    Posts
    5,584
    Post Thanks / Like
    I would say Marshall since he is proven and if reports are correct would cost us a second rounder. Bryant is still a lock for the first round and at this point we really don't know what he will develop into.

  15. #15
    All League
    Join Date
    Apr 2003
    Location
    Pensacola, FL
    Posts
    3,095
    Post Thanks / Like
    For those of you that would take Bryant - its on the same level as picking Colt McCoy over Jay Cutler. Really bizarre.

    The only player to have issues under Rex has been a player that was more concerned with his own personal exposure rather than his team. In Maarshall's case, he was an immature child upon entering the league then showed is concern with winning when Mangini II sent their Pro Bowl Qb packing.

    Marshall is probably the 4th best WR in the game behind Fitz, A Johnson, and Calvin Johnson.

    The ONLY reason not to make the move for Marshall is economics. That I will understand. Not taking him becasue you think he sucks or is a bad person, well we already have players who:

    Smoke Pot
    Have several children out of wedlock and won't pay CS
    Have charges brought against them because of problems stemming from bar activities.

    I understand that many uninformed people blamed BM for Wiliams death, but Marshall had nothing to do with the idiot who actually pulled the gun and fired.

    I think Marshall needs a new address and will excell if given the opportunity.

    Could help MS develop into the Pro Bowl QB we have all hope for.

  16. #16
    Banned
    Join Date
    Apr 2008
    Location
    NYC
    Posts
    9,157
    Post Thanks / Like
    Quote Originally Posted by pcola View Post
    For those of you that would take Bryant - its on the same level as picking Colt McCoy over Jay Cutler. Really bizarre.
    Enough said. And I think Bryant is very talented. Mediocre Combine or not the guy has the tools.

  17. #17
    Hall Of Fame
    Join Date
    Mar 2007
    Posts
    8,280
    Post Thanks / Like
    ^^ And the skillz.

  18. #18
    Hall Of Fame
    Join Date
    Aug 2005
    Location
    Jersey
    Posts
    2,843
    Post Thanks / Like
    Neither. I want a DE or OLB in the worst out of this draft. Failing that, I'd love the pick to be Devin McCourty.

    But if I absolutely had to choose it I think it would be Bryant. They both look like headcases but Bryant is the younger headcase with more upside.

  19. #19
    Veteran
    Join Date
    Aug 2006
    Posts
    1,069
    Post Thanks / Like
    Before we compare Marshal with Ellis smoking pot, or Cromartie refusing to wear condoms, read this

    http://sports.espn.go.com/espn/otl/n...ory?id=4216417


    Oct. 31, 2004: During his junior year at the University of Central Florida, Brandon Marshall faced misdemeanor charges of trespass, resisting arrest without violence, disorderly conduct, refusal to obey and assault on a police officer after an argument with an off-duty Florida Highway Patrol officer turned heated at an Orlando Denny's restaurant. According to the off-duty officer, Marshall, who'd been asked to leave the restaurant for creating a disturbance, accused the officer and the restaurant manager of being "racist," threatened to sue Denny's and the Florida Highway Patrol and said he was "a star and a well-known athlete." Marshall screamed profanities and locked his fists as if he were preparing to strike the officer, according to the report. The charges were later dismissed.



    April 8, 2005: Marshall was charged with retail theft, a misdemeanor, after trying to return a stolen set of bed sheets, valued at $19.99, to a Burlington Coat Factory, according to a police report of the incident. The charge was later dropped.



    April 2006: Marshall was drafted by the Broncos in the fourth round of the NFL draft, No. 119 overall.



    Courtsey of Rasheedah Watley
    Brandon Marshall and Rasheedah Watley had dated since they were teenagers.

    June 17, 2006: Conflicting police reports from Marshall and Rasheedah Watley were filed with the Orange County, Fla., Sheriff's Department. Marshall told police that Watley became violent after seeing him earlier that evening as the object of another woman's affection. Marshall described Watley to police as an old family friend and told police that Watley punched him and scratched his chest after an argument inside the couple's Orlando apartment spiraled out of control. Watley, who filed a police report by phone from Atlanta three days after the incident, told Florida police that Marshall was the aggressor, and that he slapped her in the face, grabbed her by the arms and pushed her to the ground, and that Marshall's sister, London, who was also present during the fight, cut Watley above her eye by throwing a cell phone or remote control at her face. No charges were ever filed.



    Dec. 31, 2006: Marshall and several Broncos teammates were present at "The Shelter," a nightclub in Denver's LoDo section, as part of a birthday celebration for Denver Nuggets forward Kenyon Martin. Former Broncos wide receiver Javon Walker later told HBO's "Real Sports" that an argument broke out at the club when Marshall and his cousin sprayed champagne on another club patron and his friend. The men, who argued with Marshall and his cousin, were then asked to leave the club, Walker told HBO. Walker admitted he didn't see the encounter. According to media reports, around closing time, Marshall and his cousin were seen on the sidewalk outside the club arguing with the patrons who had been ejected from the club earlier that night. Walker told HBO that he believes the argument contributed to a drive-by shooting a short time later that killed Broncos cornerback Darrent Williams.



    Jan. 24, 2007: Police responded to a parking lot outside an Orlando bowling alley where Marshall and his father had a heated argument. According to a police report of the incident, Frederick Marshall said his son took out a handgun and fired one shot at him after the two men argued. Frederick Marshall, who refused to sign a sworn statement or press charges, said his son left the area after firing the handgun. Several witnesses said they never heard gunshots, according to the police report. While officers spoke with Frederick Marshall that evening, Brandon Marshall returned to the parking lot and provided his own statement. Brandon Marshall told police that his father had asked him for money earlier that night and that when he said "no," Frederick Marshall left the bowling alley in anger, broke a beer bottle on Brandon Marshall's vehicle and then tried to run down Brandon Marshall with his car, forcing him to jump between two vehicles in the parking lot to avoid getting hit, according to the report. Frederick Marshall also threatened to "ruin [Brandon's] professional football career," according to the police report. Brandon Marshall also declined to press charges.



    March 18, 2007: Atlanta police responded to a domestic dispute call at the Westin Peachtree hotel. Watley told officers that after meeting Marshall at the hotel that night, he became enraged after he went through her cell phone call list and noticed she'd been speaking with an ex-boyfriend. Watley told police Marshall hit her repeatedly with a closed fist. While she refused medical attention, police noticed a large, dark-colored bruise on Watley's chin. Police reported seeing Marshall in the lobby of a neighboring hotel but, according to the report, Marshall left and was not arrested. Police advised Watley to take out a warrant for Marshall's arrest, but Watley never did. No charges were ever filed.



    March 21, 2007: Watley filed a report with police in Boca Raton, Fla. Watley and Marshall, who were staying in south Florida with Marshall's uncle, told police that an argument started that night at a local restaurant after Marshall refused to ask Watley to marry him. According to a police report, while Watley was walking home, Marshall grabbed a large pipe from a construction site and hit the ground with it in frustration. Nobody was hurt. Police characterized the incident as a verbal domestic dispute. No charges were filed.



    March 26, 2007: Police in Douglas County, Colo., arrested Marshall for false imprisonment and domestic violence. Watley told "Outside the Lines" she was assaulted by Marshall a day earlier at Marshall's suburban Denver home -- she never reported that incident to police -- and that she was attempting to fly back to Atlanta to get away from Marshall. Watley told police she and Marshall argued at the Denver airport and that she later agreed to return to Marshall's home. Watley told police when she attempted to leave Marshall's home a second time, Marshall followed her taxi and, at one point, blocked its path with his Dodge Charger, leapt from his car and punched the taxi cab's windows. When contacted by "Outside the Lines," the cab driver confirmed Watley's version of events. Marshall denied punching the taxi cab's windows and later told police he was only trying to retrieve his cell phone, which he said Watley had taken from him.



    May 25, 2007: Charges against Marshall relating to his arrest in Douglas County, Colo., were dismissed after he successfully completed anger management classes.



    Courtesy of Vienna Watley
    Watley suffered a cut to her thigh during an altercation in their Atlanta condo in June 2007.

    June 8, 2007: Police responded to Marshall and Watley's Atlanta condo at 5 a.m. and found Watley with a noticeable cut on her right thigh. Watley initially told officers that she accidentally cut herself with a kitchen knife. Watley told the first officer to arrive that while she had argued with Marshall earlier that evening, no physical abuse occurred. Marshall was not present. Roughly an hour later, at 6:07 a.m., police were dispatched to the condo a second time. On this second visit Watley told police that Marshall did indeed cut her thigh with a kitchen knife during a fight earlier that evening and that he later returned to the condo and continued to assault Watley by punching her in the forehead. Watley's friend, Kristeena Spivey, told police that while she was attempting to drive Watley from the condo complex, she noticed Marshall attempting to leave the scene. Spivey, who called 911 to make officers aware of Marshall's whereabouts, said when she attempted to block Marshall's exit from the parking lot with her vehicle, Marshall rammed her car with his Cadillac Escalade and then left his SUV and threw a large rock at the passenger side of Spivey's car. Marshall fled the scene before police arrived, according to Spivey and Watley. Watley was taken to Grady Memorial Hospital for treatment. No charges were ever filed.



    June 30, 2007: Atlanta police responded to a fight-in-progress call at Marshall and Watley's condo. Watley told police that a fight broke out after Marshall missed a flight and blamed Watley. Watley told police Marshall struck her with a closed fist and choked her. Watley had a bruise on her left eye and noticeable scratches on her body, according to a police report of the incident. Officers made Watley aware of the procedures to obtain a restraining order. No charges were filed.



    Oct. 22, 2007: Hours after defeating the Pittsburgh Steelers, Marshall was cited at 2 a.m. by Denver police for driving under the influence after he was seen driving erratically. His blood-alcohol level was 0.116 (the legal limit for DUI in Colorado is 0.08).



    Jan. 18, 2008: Watley obtained a temporary protective order against Marshall in Fulton County (Ga.) Superior Court. At the time, Marshall was forbidden to come within 200 yards of Watley. Watley, through her attorneys, eventually agreed to lift the court order.



    Feb. 18, 2008: Watley told "Outside the Lines" that as part of a Valentine's Day present, and in an attempt to repair their relationship, Marshall surprised her with a last-minute trip to San Juan, Puerto Rico. While on that trip, Watley said, Marshall argued with her about an ex-boyfriend. Watley said Marshall assaulted her at San Juan's Condado Plaza Hotel, hitting her in the mouth, which caused her to bleed, and choking her on the bed. A report was filed by police saying officers were called to the hotel to help hotel security escort guests from the property. The report does not mention Watley, Marshall or any details of the incident.



    March 4, 2008: Police responded around 9 p.m. to a fight call at Marshall and Watley's Atlanta condo and found Marshall bleeding from his hand. Marshall initially told police that during an argument with Watley, one of Watley's sisters cut him on his hand with a knife. When asked by police who had the knife, Marshall then told officers there was no knife, and that he'd been cut on glass during a fight with Watley. Watley told police that Marshall became upset after finding text messages from an ex-boyfriend on Watley's phone. Watley had several cuts on her lips, according to a police report, and told officers that Marshall had grabbed her by the head and slapped her. While police were interviewing Watley, Marshall fled, according to a report of the incident.



    March 5, 2008: Police returned to Marshall and Watley's condo around 1 a.m. Watley and her sister both told police that after the fight earlier that same evening, Marshall returned to the condo, took Watley's purse and threw her personal belongings, including clothing, off of the 20th floor balcony. Police told Watley to leave the residence, but she declined and explained that she feared Marshall would return again once officers left and damage more of her property.



    March 5, 2008: Watley obtained her second temporary protective order against Marshall in Fulton County Superior Court. Marshall was once again forbidden by the court order to come within 200 yards of Watley.



    May 5, 2008: Atlanta police were called once again to the condo Watley shared for more than a year with Marshall. According to a police report, Watley and Marshall's mother argued about Watley's attempt to remove items from the condo. No charges were filed.



    Aug. 5, 2008: The NFL released a statement announcing that Marshall would be suspended without pay for the Broncos' first three regular-season games of 2008 for violating the NFL personal conduct policy. The statement noted that "if Marshall fully complies with required counseling and other conditions of the suspension, Commissioner Goodell will consider reducing the suspension to two games."



    Aug. 28, 2008: Less than a month after the NFL released a statement announcing Marshall's suspension, the league released another statement saying Marshall's suspension had been reduced upon appeal to one game without pay plus an additional fine of one game check. An NFL spokesman told ESPN "a potential reduction in [Marshall's] initial three-game suspension was always contemplated if he complied with required counseling and other conditions of the suspension." The spokesman would not elaborate on the precise conditions Marshall met to have his suspension reduced.



    Sept. 10, 2008: Marshall was charged with two misdemeanor counts of simple battery as a result of the incident the previous March (his formal bond arraignment was Nov. 3, 2008). Simple battery, according to the Fulton County District Attorney's office, is punishable by up to one year in jail and/or a $1,000 fine.



    Sept. 12, 2008: Nearly a year after being cited for DUI in Denver, Marshall pleaded guilty to the lesser offense of driving while ability-impaired. He was sentenced to one year of probation.



    Feb. 5, 2009: While attending a dinner party in Honolulu as part of his Pro Bowl appearance, Marshall proposed to Michi Nogami-Campbell. Marshall told the Denver Post he met Nogami-Campbell while the two attended the University of Central Florida. The engagement prompted several sports writers to praise what they characterized as Marshall's maturity.



    March 1, 2009: Marshall and his fiancée, Nogami-Campbell, were seen by an off-duty Atlanta police officer arguing outside the same Atlanta condo Marshall once shared with Watley. According to a police report of the incident, the off-duty officer saw Marshall and Nogami-Campbell kicking and punching one another on the sidewalk outside the condo building. The off-duty officer said she saw Marshall grab Nogami-Campbell by the shirt and pin her up against the wall. Nogami-Campbell continued to kick and hit Marshall, the officer said. Both Marshall and Nogami-Campbell were arrested and taken to the Atlanta City Jail. They were released later that same day and charges were dismissed. In a statement to ESPN, the NFL said the incident remains "under review."

  20. #20
    Jets Insider VIP
    JetsInsider.com Legend
    Charter JI Member

    Join Date
    May 1999
    Posts
    31,407
    Post Thanks / Like
    Quote Originally Posted by VincenzoTestaverde View Post
    Bryant is very talented but he's a flake and NFL WR's need to work at their craft to be effective (practice route running, develop chemistry with their QB's etc.). Would rather have Marshall. McDouchebag has lost all his leverage and would maybe settle for a 2nd for Marshall by now.
    so you don't want Bryant because he's a flake and would rather have Marshall??? Why- is marshall not a flake???

    Quote Originally Posted by VincenzoTestaverde View Post
    Enough said. And I think Bryant is very talented. Mediocre Combine or not the guy has the tools.
    good point....except bryant didn't work out at the combine....

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  

Follow Us