the NY Jets, win media headlines, the NY Giants win SB's. 4 SB's since 1986
If you hate the jets so damn much just go be a giants fan already. You might as well be a giants troll (pretty sure you are anyway). You never add a freakin piece of insight to any thread you post in. Summary of your contributions:Originally Posted by bigdanNJ
"Fire Tanenbum"
"The Jets suck. Giants are awesome"
Give it a rest already.
It took him 14 years to win a bowl how long would he last here??
He was in the playoffs almost every year and made plenty of deep runs. And that was without ever having a franchise QB until Ben in 2004. And once Ben got there, bang, he wins the SB a year later. If Cowher would actually take the job - which I doubt, as someone pointed out in another thread he turned down Woody once before - you have to go get him.
His teams failed badly in the playoffs when they were the favorites. 10 out of 15 years he was in the playoffs and had an 8-9 playoff record until his super bowl year. I would bet that if you gave Rex 15 years he can pull off one Superbowl win as well. Cowher = somewhat overrated. Very few past glory coaches resurface and have the same success they had before.
I believe in Rex Ryan as a HC. So if Tanny ends up getting canned, Woody should approach the hiring process telling every candidate, "Rex Ryan is our HC".
As a Bills fan who has followed Bill Polian's career for more than 2 decades, I would be very wary of hiring him.
- He's good at building a team but NOT in sustaining it under the salary cap.
- I question his evaluation of HCs, including Marv Levy but particularly Jim Caldwell. John Fox and Tony Dungy were okay.
- I question his philosophy on what a good team should be. In Buffalo, he built did NOT build a physical enough team to compete with the cream of the NFC; he seemed satisfied for the Bills to be a big fish in little pond. In Indy, he did NOT build a big enough, physical enough defensive team, either. He built a defense totally and completely dependent upon getting and holding a big lead.
- He also allowed nepotism to influence his decisions in Indy. His son did a very bad job as the player-personnel guy in that organization. Indy's recent drafts were very thin, which also contributed to the 2011 collapse.
- I do NOT care who your QB is, he should NOT be making decisions for the coaching staff, and that is what I heard/read was the modus operendus on the Colts team; Manning pretty much dictated what went in practice. As GM, it was on him to know that was going on and to do something about it, especially when it impacted the team, as in, the backup QB getting even fewer reps than backup QBs normally get.
For second part, picking up a RT, there simply aren't any healthy NFL caliber ones to be had at this point. I suspect that there won't be many available except until possibly at the last cut down date.
Are you just talking about coaches who won the SB? I will assume not. But off the top of my head I can think of:
- Parcells: went to a SB with his second team, and should have gone to a SB with his third team (Jets).
- Jimmy Johnson: had a declining Marino in Miami but resurrected their defense and running game and they were always contenders.
- Tony Dungy: resurrected the Bucs and then the Colts.
- Tom Coughlin - very successful in Jax and we know what he's done with the she-men.
- Dan Reeves and Marty Schottenheimer were both successful in their second (and third) go-arounds.
Obviously there are some that weren't so successful with their 2nd team (Holmgren comes to mind) but otherwise this seems like a bad reason to not pursue Cowher, if it ever comes to that.
The real question is: How many SB rings and/ or AFC championship rings does he have?
A RT will shake loose shortly. I understand VERNON CAREY is comtemplating coming out of retirement for starters. Time alone will tell.
That was a well written post HD. I hope the Bills do well except against the Jets. Welcome to JI.
Very solid post. And I agree - one SB victory between 2 HOF quarterbacks over the course of - what - 20 seasons. I mean, I'd take it as a Jets fan, but it isn't all that impressive.
I'm not defending Polian here, but be fair: 6 SB appearances in 20 seasons is pretty f'ing impressive. It's not his fault they lost on a missed FG to the giants and an amazing onside kick to the saints.
Totally true - I was just playing devil's advocate. For a front-office guy, he did put them in position to win at a good clip - which is probably all a front-office can do.
But I always felt Indy resembled Marino-era Dolphins too much - never quite going out and getting everything they needed to compete because they had a QB who they felt could take up the slack.
The same fans who want to bring Cowher here, are the same fans who would have wanted him fired in Pittsburgh before he actually won the Super Bowl.It took him 14 years to win a bowl how long would he last here??
I felt a lot of that had to do with Manning not being as good of a playoff QB as his rep would indicate. Kerry Byrne, creator of Cold Hard Football Facts (great site with self made meta stats that actually correlate to performance on the field), has made that assertion many times. The one time they did win an SB it was on the back of a defense that stifled the opposition with lackluster support from Manning save the ridiculous comeback against the Pats. I am more a fan of Polian's work in Buffalo and just the overall resume.
It is not perfect by any means as the Bills fan (welcome sir, you seem like a solid poster) mentioned. But I think he is a better match for Rex (might solve Polian's inability to pick a great coach) than Mr. T. This assuming Tanny doesn't prove me wrong with the season, I would love to eat crow on this one.
seriously ?
Were all 100 of your posts this awesome... just wondering
Big game for Hunter coming up(crazy to say that for your starting RT). If he plays like Saturday I believe the CS has to bench him for the benefit of the team. The Stephon Heyer cut is somewhat telling as he was Hunter's backup who they signed as a FA.
Like any other team veteran cuts will be explored unless the Jets fold and give away a draft pick for a player that may be cut anyway..
I know many Jets fans are not too confident in the offense at this point however they have played only 2 preseason games without all their weapons while learning a new system. I agree some things need fixing but I think most teams have issues that need fixing after 2 games. I don't understand all the gloom and doom around this site. After one bad year (not even a losing season) people are calling for coaching changes and firings. It's so pathetic to read all the negative comments. Yea it's tough losing to the Giants again but at least the jets are relatively healthy for the most part at this point in the season.
Do we even know for sure that we need to fix the offense or is it that they just need more time to execute the plays? I think they have 4 pre season games for that am I mistaken? We all know that they won't play much on 3 days rest vs philly for the last game so that leaves game 3 vs Carolina sunday night. I am pretty certain that this is the game the playbooks will open and the starters will be all playing and not resting anymore injuries. You will see a more efficient offense and you will see Tebow and Sanchez on the field together trying out some plays. I would be surprised if Rex didn't at least do that to see how it's all going to work. I think the team needs a confidence boost as well as us fans. That being said if we see another quiet output from the Offense this week than I could not imagine the fans getting up for the opener vs Buffalo. Cmon Rex! lets see what you got!! Prove to us that its all gunna come together.
In 1992 we went 5-0 in the preseason and 4-12 in the regular season. Maybe the reverse will happen this year lol
Thanks for the history lesson douchebag
+100000000
Posting Permissions
Reply With Quote
Bookmarks