In the words of Yoda:Not top-tier, obviously, but far from the bottom as well.
Do or do not, there is no try.
This team is waaaaaaaaayyyyyyy overdue to win a Super Bowl.
If you haven't noticed, since 2002, there hasn't been a Super Bowl winner without a guaranteed or borderline Hall of Fame quarterback.
Of the QB's who have won the Super Bowl in that time frame, only Tom Brady was drafted lower than the 2nd round.
A GM who is great at evaluating QB talent is a huge must today.
I would sign Polian, have him draft us a QB after tanking a year or two (which is how Polian works to guarantee the #1 pick) then fire Polian since he only is good at doing just what I said (unless you consider continually losing conference Championship games "good enough," in which case please go root for the Bills or Pats,) then bring a Giants GM and go win titles.