Just comes down to how good these guys are. Truthfully, it really only comes down to how good Geno is.
Obviously a lot hinges on Smith, but if Winters becomes a solid starter and Richardson/Milliner turn into pro bowl players you can't look at this draft and complain. Geno failing is as bad as any other 2nd rounder that fails. Its not like the Jets are investing that much in him.
Not true at all. Geno is a 2nd round pick making minimum money because of the rookie wage scale. We can easily take a qb next year if we deem he is not the answer.
A 2nd round pick with the rookie wage scale does not make or break your draft.
Your missing the point if you think that Dee & Sheldon are less important than a QB who may not play this season. We picked him at a value spot and at the most he will cost us a combined $5m over the next 5 years. That's great for a backup QB even if he doesn't pan out as a Franchise QB. For that, you take the risk and pass on any of the other prospects that we could've had at the point of the 2nd round because the possibility of him becoming a franchise QB is too great to pass up on. Imagine for a second the ridicule we would have gotten if we passed him up for a Safety or WR? They would be killing us in the press.