Results 1 to 16 of 16

Thread: Great article on QB play from Grantland

  1. #1
    Veteran
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Location
    Washington, DC
    Posts
    1,846

    Great article on QB play from Grantland

    I would highly recommend checking out the article here http://www.grantland.com/story/_/id/...each-greatness because it contains good video examples of what the article is talking about, but I thought there were several points in the article (that I've bolded) that really explain some of the things that Sanchez is unable to do, which will, IMO, prevent him from ever being a good NFL QB.

    The most important thing, IMO, that the article talks about is that good quarterbacks need to instantaneously be able to mentally shift from their first receiver to their secondary targets. I think Sanchez can't do this. When Sanchez 's first target is open and Sanchez can throw in rhythm, he's as good as any QB in the NFL, but the moment that something breaks down, he morphs into a QB who is unable to play at an NFL level. I think this is the most important skill for an NFL QB to have, and it might also be the hardest to scout, because generally, college QBs don't need to do this because their first reads are generally open. Anyway, I just thought I'd share this piece.

    Jim Mora's "Playoffs?! Playoffs?!" rant is, along with other feel-good moments like "They are who we thought they were!" and "Go play intramurals, brother!," in the pantheon of unhinged postgame outbursts. Resurrected every year just prior to, yes, the playoffs, it sticks with us because in one nasal-inflected word Mora revealed everything about himself at that moment: He was a doomed man, something confirmed just weeks later when he was fired.

    Yet the most interesting aspect of the rant is that almost everyone forgets the real target of the coach's ire. Mora was squarely and publicly laying the blame for his team's ugly loss to the 49ers at the feet of his team's young franchise quarterback some guy named Peyton Manning.

    "Do not blame that game on the defense, OK?" said Mora. "When you turn the ball over five times four interceptions, one for a touchdown, three others in field position to set up touchdowns you ain't going to beat anybody."

    Keep in mind that, by 2001, Manning had been to the Pro Bowl twice and had compiled a 23-9 record over the prior two seasons. Still, Mora was unrelenting. "I don't know who the hell we think we are when we do something like that," said Mora. "Unbelievable. Pitiful. It's absolutely pitiful to perform like that." Although publicly ripping your franchise player is hardly advisable, Mora wasn't wrong; Manning had played kind of awfully, and his 23 interceptions that season coupled with the league's 31st-ranked scoring defense had gone a long way in sending the Colts to a 6-10 record and ultimately costing Mora his job.

    Few remember that Mora was talking about Peyton Manning because Peyton Manning has spent the past 12 years making us forget. Manning has been so good for so long that we can barely remember a time before he and Tom Brady were the game's best. Mora's tirade acts as a reminder that not even Manning arrived in the NFL as a fully formed star quarterback. He and Brady had their own struggles early on; the remarkable thing is not where they are now, but how far they've come.

    Since Mora's outburst, Manning has become a Super Bowl champion and solidified his status as one of the greatest quarterbacks of all time. He's closer to the end of his career than the beginning, and before long, he and Brady will be off to sell pizzas or pick Kentucky Derby winners or do whatever else football immortals do when their playing days are over. When they do move on, the spots atop the quarterback hierarchy will be open again, and the question will be who takes up the mantle. Aaron Rodgers looks like a lock for greatness, but the other worthy contenders from Russell Wilson to Robert Griffin III to Andrew Luck, and even Joe Flacco are by no means finished products. Each has a long way to go before he can be considered a master of his craft.

    No position is more scrutinized How tall is he? How far can he throw? Who is he dating? and nowhere in football is greatness valued or debated more, but exactly how young, promising quarterbacks become Tom Brady and Peyton Manning remains something of a mystery. The results are apparent, but most are unversed in the actual process. Manning, Brady, and Rodgers are great because they've taken the raw materials of the position an understanding of defenses, of why receivers get open and how to find them and transformed them into muscle memory they can use to fluidly perform, every time. Greatness isn't something quarterbacks stumble upon. It's something that becomes ingrained into their very constitution.

    It's no secret Peyton Manning works pretty hard. In April, he and his brother Eli, along with their top pass-catching targets, spent time on Duke's campus with Blue Devils head coach David Cutcliffe, who coached Peyton and Eli in college. At this stage, both brothers have seen their share of football 2013 will be Eli's 10th season in the league but in traveling to Durham, Peyton wanted to go back to the beginning. He asked Cutcliffe for a return to the basics, to "coach us like we were both freshmen at Tennessee or Ole Miss."

    When Cutcliffe trains a young quarterback, he begins with his most valuable asset: his mind. "I do not talk about passing routes with them for one month," Cutcliffe said at a coaches clinic in 2011. "All we do is teach them defense for a month. We teach them the history of defense. We teach them the history of the zone blitz. We teach them what it is, and what is happening in the defense. Once the quarterback learns coverages, it enables them to move on in the teaching progression."

    In football's earliest days, the forward pass was primarily about surprising the defense or attacking a single, isolated defender locked in man coverage. As defenses got more sophisticated, offenses evolved too, with the largest contribution coming from former San Diego Chargers head coach Sid Gillman, the "Father of the Passing Game." Gillman refined passing into a calibrated, organized attack. His insights inform every throw you'll see this fall.

    Realizing that a football field is nothing more than a 53⅓-yard-wide geometric plane, Gillman designed his pass patterns to stretch defenses past their breaking points. His favorite method was to divide the field into five passing lanes and then allocate five receivers horizontally in each one. Against most zones, at least one receiver would be open. Below is an image from one of Gillman's final playbooks with the Philadelphia Eagles.
    Tom Brady
    Courtesy of Chris Brown

    Along with stretching defenses left to right and right to left, Gillman also stretched them deep to short, by putting two or three receivers on the same vertical line. With Gillman's ideas in mind, well-designed pass plays today still combine horizontal or vertical stretches with routes also designed to defeat man coverage. This means that as long as a quarterback can read the defense, he can find an open receiver. That, however, is the trick. As Gillman liked to write in his quarterbacks' playbooks: "You must know the theory of all coverages. Without this knowledge you are dead."

    A quarterback translates his knowledge of defenses and passing plays to the field through his reads, of which there are two basic types: progression and coverage. "A progression read is a pass play where three or more receivers are looked to in a one, two, three progression. 'Is he open? Is he open? Is he open?'" Cutcliffe explained at a coaching clinic. With a coverage read, it's "the coverage played by the defense" that determines which receivers the quarterback looks for.

    A few decades ago, simple if-then coverage reads were the most common way to teach a young quarterback how to find an open receiver. If the key defender dropped one way, the quarterback threw the ball to, say, his tight end, but if the defender dropped the other way, the quarterback threw it to the wide receiver. As defenses have become increasingly sophisticated, quarterbacks now need more options than simple key-defender reads provide. The answer was the progression read, which forces a quarterback to look at one receiver after another until he gets to the first open man. The progression read removes the need to look directly at defenders, but it doesn't mean a quarterback should be looking directly at receivers, either.

    "I don't tell our guys to look at a defender," Georgia head coach Mark Richt said at a coaching clinic. "If our quarterback is looking at a defender, then his vision is too tight. Let's say he looks at the Will [weakside] linebacker and the Will linebacker flies out to the flat. If he flies out to the flat, I better hit the slant, right? Well, what if the Mike [middle linebacker] runs that way and picks your slant? It's because you told him to look at the Will."

    The quarterback isn't looking for defenders. He's looking for passing lanes open windows through which he can throw the ball. "I tell them to look to the area," said Richt. "You look to the slant area, to the curl area. If there's nothing between you and him, throw it in there. If there's someone in the throwing lane, then go to the next read."

    Most modern passing plays may use progressions, but that still leaves open the question of which progression, and the answer is what brings everything together. It's a coverage read that determines the quarterback's progression. It was Gillman who developed one of the earliest and most effective tools for this, the idea of the "best-located safety," which he defined as the "safety which is lined up in a position that is least likely to be able to assist in the coverage of a wide receiver. In other words, he's the furthest removed and best to attack!" Most NFL teams still use the idea of the best-located safety as a coverage key,1 but it's only one of several.

    Good passing teams package different pass concepts together to give their quarterbacks answers versus a variety of defenses. The coverage read on a given play is tied to these pass concepts. For example, if the route combination to one side is better against single-safety defenses like Cover Three, and the concept to the other side is better against two-deep, split-safety coverages, then the quarterback's read will be based on the number of safeties.

    Given the byzantine schemes defenses have used in recent years, simple coverage keys aren't always enough to identify an open receiver. Aside from the usual veteran quarterback tricks look-offs, dummy signals, and so on Brady and Manning are better than other quarterbacks because they can process more information. They see not only the number of deep safeties, but the depth and leverage of the cornerbacks and the alignment of the linebackers. They see the entire defensive structure.

    This is not to say they always (or even usually) know the exact coverage, but their years of study and practice allow them to make an instant judgment about the basic tactics of a defense and where it's weakest. For example, while mounting a furious comeback against the 49ers last season, the Patriots lined up with a different route concept to each side of the formation: a curl/flat concept to Brady's left and the Levels concept to his right. Curl/flat is a horizontal stretch on the defense that works best against single-safety defenses like Cover Three, whereas Levels is a vertical or high/low stretch that works best against two-safety defenses. New England tied those concepts together with a Seam Read route by Wes Welker, whose job was to either stay up the seam against a single middle safety or split two deep ones.
    Chris Brown
    Courtesy of Chris Brown

    Brady's progressions on the play were either (1) Seam Read, (2) curl, and (3) flat; or, if looking the other way, (1) Seam Read, (2) deep square-in, and (3) short square-in. What made his task more difficult is that the 49ers typically use a lot of hybrid defenses, frequently playing different coverages to each side of the field, specifically to confuse a quarterback's coverage keys.

    On this play, the 49ers align in what appears to be Quarter-Quarter-Half coverage, with Cover Four or Quarters to the offense's left and a type of Two-Deep to its right. Where some quarterbacks may get confused, Brady did not. He knew that the inside safety to his left had to defend Welker's seam route, and when he did, it transformed the coverage to that side into essentially a single-safety type of coverage, one perfect for the curl/flat combination to Brady's left. As Brady dropped he confirmed the coverage, saw Welker blanketed, and calmly delivered the ball to Brandon Lloyd on a curl for a first down.

    bradyread

    No matter how much he's prepared, for an NFL quarterback, the moment just after the snap is bedlam. Cornerbacks who looked like they were in soft coverage roll up to press receivers, unexpected blitzers come tearing off the edge, and savvy safeties start on one side of the field only to fly to the other. It's also the most critical moment. Regardless of what bizarre look the defense showed before the snap, once the play begins, it must reveal its true intentions.

    This is why, on their initial steps away from the line the first step in a three-step drop, or the first three steps in a five-step drop quarterbacks must keep their eyes directly down the middle of the field and use their peripheral vision to see how the defense, in particular the safeties, rotate and align. Gillman called this "reading the square," and not only is it crucial for a quarterback's read, it also provides a natural look-off. The quarterback gives nothing away when he looks deep down the middle. By the end of his drop, the quarterback should grasp enough of his coverage read to decide which progression of receivers he'll look to. At that point it's as simple as reading one, two, three in theory.

    The next step is not only making the right read but making it at the right time. Receivers in the NFL are open for only the briefest of moments, and "too often," according to former 49ers head coach Bill Walsh, "either the quarterback is standing there waiting for the receiver, or the receiver has broken before the quarterback can throw the ball." Being too early or too late is usually no different from being wrong.


    Careful calibration of the timing between quarterbacks and receivers is a fundamental element of making an offense work. By defining a quarterback's drops by the specific number of steps taken, offenses can synchronize the quarterback's movements with the routes of the receivers; the timing between when a quarterback is ready to throw and when the receiver is ready to receive the ball must be perfect. Specifically, the quarterback's first read should be thrown to when his last step hits the ground. This is what is known as a "rhythm" throw.2

    Now, let's say the quarterback's first read isn't open. How does he know when to move to the next receiver? The idea of finding a secondary receiver leaves some quarterbacks looking like they just lost their wallet. For others, like Brady or Manning, it looks easy, and it's because it's not only their brains telling them when to look.

    "His feet are telling him when to move to no. 2 and no. 3," current San Francisco head coach Jim Harbaugh said to a room full of quarterback coaches back when he was coaching at the University of San Diego. "One-two-three-four-five-plant throw it. If it's not there, first hitch is to the [second read], and then the second hitch is to [third read]."

    This must be precise. "If you have a passing system where he's dropping back and waiting for a guy to come open, a lot of bad stuff is going to happen," said Harbaugh. When Brady hits the last step of his drop in the play from earlier, he's in perfect position to throw the rhythm seam to Welker except Welker isn't open. He then calmly bounces in place, resetting his feet while remaining in perfect balance, and throws a strike.

    bradyread

    Often, we associate being great with being spectacular, but that's the secret about playing quarterback great quarterbacks seek the banality of perfection. It's about avoiding the bad play, hitting the right receiver, making the right read, and throwing an accurate pass, every time. Mora was absolutely right when he said you simply cannot win if your quarterback makes critical mistakes.


    The process of becoming that player is only so complex. Defenses, reads, and coverages can all be learned in time. It just takes a truly dedicated player with a disciplined mind to see that process to its end. Played out as far as it will go, those decisions and movements are no longer conscious ones. For the best quarterbacks, it goes beyond making the right read and correct progression. The elements of great quarterbacking become a part of their very makeup as players. According to Bill Walsh, "because of the dynamic role he plays on the team, a quarterback must have physical, mental, emotional and instinctive traits that go well beyond the mere ability to pass a football." If the league's young quarterbacks want to be truly great, they'll have to master something that comes from the combination of all those traits, something that can't really be coached, something Brady and Manning have both done for years.

    "Does he make everyone around him better?" Duke's Cutcliffe asked rhetorically in 2011. "We have all played with those types of quarterbacks, we have coached them, or we have seen them. That is the greatest gift the quarterback can have."

  2. #2
    Practice Squad
    Join Date
    Sep 2011
    Posts
    282
    Brilliant article and great interpretation. Sanchez is just that; he's stuck in college mode and refuses to adapt his game. What a putz. If your progression are not there you throw the ball away. Always maintain control of the offense while hell is breaking loose around you. Maybe he'll begin to change now.

  3. #3
    Jets Insider VIP
    Join Date
    Jan 2006
    Location
    One hour. from MetLife
    Posts
    22,292
    Wow Peyton was just like Sanchez early on.

  4. #4
    Great article! Thanks! At this level, it's more about what's between the ears, and not as much a gun for an arm. A gun doesnt hurt, but you have to be able to process what is happening in real-time to have any chance at being successful. This is Mark's biggest downfall. If his first read is not there, he panics. Too bad. Hopefully Geno can process things more quickly. The interview with Gruden gives me hope. We shall see....

  5. #5
    Quote Originally Posted by RMJK View Post
    Wow Peyton was just like Sanchez early on.
    Did you feel that breeze going over your head? You know what that was? The point of the article. LOL J/K

  6. #6
    All League
    Join Date
    Oct 2004
    Location
    Brooklyn, NY
    Posts
    2,731
    Fantastic article!!! This is the stuff fans should read not the crap from ESPN

  7. #7
    Quote Originally Posted by KRL View Post
    Fantastic article!!! This is the stuff fans should read not the crap from ESPN
    Um, ESPN owns Grantland.

  8. #8
    Quote Originally Posted by positive View Post
    Brilliant article and great interpretation. Sanchez is just that; he's stuck in college mode and refuses to adapt his game. What a putz. If your progression are not there you throw the ball away. Always maintain control of the offense while hell is breaking loose around you. Maybe he'll begin to change now.
    There is absolutely NOTHING to suggest that will happen. He STILL looks like a rookie and Geno is surpassing him QUICKLY.
    That's the biggest thing I saw re Geno specifically in the Gruden video.... Mainly "reading the square" Something Geno understood before he was drafted and something Sanchez never will.

  9. #9
    This article, IMO, shows where Belicheck truly may have become a legendary coach. We must remember he was the defensive genius long ago. He was the mind of all minds when it came to defense. Tom Brady on the surface is an average build, an average arm, pretty much everything average there is about a QB. But he definitely is smart and he clearly was determined. He wanted to be the best QB in the league. When he told Robert Kraft that drafting him was the best decision of his life (before he ever became the Tom Brady we know), I think it gave a darn good insight into the level of determination the kid had to overcome his physical "averageness" to be great. Belicheck at the time was beginning to take a true interest in offense, and I think his ultimate watershed moment was passing on his genius knowledge of NFL defensive schemes to an ever willing sponge in Tom Brady. Watch the Pats, it seems like Brady is passing to a wide open guy on every play. That's because Brady knows exactly what the defense is doing every time. It's also why he completely crumbles when faced with alot of pressure up the middle. It takes away that one second extra processing time to understand what the defense is doing and find the right guy.

    One thing is apparent, Rex has not spent alot of time with the offense. Personally I think he has no business trying to give his 2 cents on offensive philosophy. But..............I do think he could help his QB's tremendously by sitting down with them during the offseason and truly teaching them the entire defensive philosophy. Give them the insight from a DC perspective. I think this would have helped Mark out, and it certainly would help Geno. I believe just about every QB should be able to be a great DC if they really want to be successful.

  10. #10
    Such a genius, he had to cheat his way to win.

  11. #11
    This is an excellent article (and I have the say, I do like Grantland and do read it from time to time, as opposed to ESPN), and it also explains why Brady or most other QBs have trouble with the inside rush. That inside rush is disrupting their view and throwing off their field vision to the point that they have to either accelerate the process or abandon it completely.

  12. #12
    Awesome article, and the article it links to (about coverage tactics in zone blitzes) is also fantastic. Every once in a while true fans of football and not just the Jets get to read something cool like these two articles.

  13. #13
    Quote Originally Posted by Snell41 View Post
    This article, IMO, shows where Belicheck truly may have become a legendary coach. We must remember he was the defensive genius long ago. He was the mind of all minds when it came to defense. Tom Brady on the surface is an average build, an average arm, pretty much everything average there is about a QB. But he definitely is smart and he clearly was determined. He wanted to be the best QB in the league. When he told Robert Kraft that drafting him was the best decision of his life (before he ever became the Tom Brady we know), I think it gave a darn good insight into the level of determination the kid had to overcome his physical "averageness" to be great. Belicheck at the time was beginning to take a true interest in offense, and I think his ultimate watershed moment was passing on his genius knowledge of NFL defensive schemes to an ever willing sponge in Tom Brady. Watch the Pats, it seems like Brady is passing to a wide open guy on every play. That's because Brady knows exactly what the defense is doing every time. It's also why he completely crumbles when faced with alot of pressure up the middle. It takes away that one second extra processing time to understand what the defense is doing and find the right guy.

    One thing is apparent, Rex has not spent alot of time with the offense. Personally I think he has no business trying to give his 2 cents on offensive philosophy. But..............I do think he could help his QB's tremendously by sitting down with them during the offseason and truly teaching them the entire defensive philosophy. Give them the insight from a DC perspective. I think this would have helped Mark out, and it certainly would help Geno. I believe just about every QB should be able to be a great DC if they really want to be successful.
    I'm sorry, but this is a HUGE reach. It implies BB not only taught Brady his own defensive philosophy, but EVERY philosophy known to man. It also makes you wonder why BB hasn't done more with his own defense over the past few seasons. Sure he hasn't had all-pro talent, but if his defensive knowledge turned Brady into what he's become, you gotta think he could've done A LOT more than he has on the other side of the ball . . .

  14. #14
    Unlike the pay where it says "Sanchez is as good as anyone". LOL

    I know you have to read the context, but there is no context where that makes sense!

  15. #15
    Quote Originally Posted by OCCH View Post
    I'm sorry, but this is a HUGE reach. It implies BB not only taught Brady his own defensive philosophy, but EVERY philosophy known to man. It also makes you wonder why BB hasn't done more with his own defense over the past few seasons. Sure he hasn't had all-pro talent, but if his defensive knowledge turned Brady into what he's become, you gotta think he could've done A LOT more than he has on the other side of the ball . . .
    I'll rebutt this with two things. One, there is a cap. When you have a franchise QB, your money is going to that side of the ball. You do whatever is necessary to keep your offense at its highest output. Colts constantly spent money helping Manning. NO continuously gives weapons to Brees. When you have that type of QB all of your big money goes to offense and you try to draft playmakers on defense and keep them while they're cheap. It's why they traded away Seymour years ago, well before he was done. The second piggy backs on the first-Bill has tried to draft for Defense, however to be honest his one flaw is his talent evaluation in the draft. I think he has too much control there, and they've had some big whiffs on young players. Since their SB years they really have not been able to replace those solid lunchpail guys like Bruschi, Vrabel, etc.

    Belicheck definitely has his defensive philosophy, but his is far more multi-dimensional than most. He has always fielded D's that best suit the talent of his players, so the "philosophy" he taught Brady is also far more reaching. It's not a "hey I like to blitz alot and here's how you beat it". It's more "here's the formation your seeing, here's the philosophy of what they're accomplishing, here's how these positions are going to react to your formation, and here's where the soft spot will end up being". I do think Belicheck had quite a bit to do with transforming Brady from the dink and dunk QB that won his first miraculous SB to the potent potentially one of the best ever QB's ever. And I think he did that by teaching Brady the in depth philosophies of the Defense.

  16. #16
    Jets Insider VIP
    Join Date
    Aug 2007
    Location
    Paris, France
    Posts
    13,235
    Great read. The guy has a few other interesting articles at the bottom of the page.

    Thanks for posting.

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  

Follow Us