I think their 2nd biggest mistake was when Schiano did NOT call a timeout to ICE Nick Folk.
I was stunned that he didn't use the final timeout.
Disagree. Never mind that icing the kicker is not proven to be useful at all.
But if you want to ice a kicker. It's on a short kick. A 48 yard kick is fairly long. Why give a guy 2 chances at a long field goal. If he misses the first he has a chance to make it and figure out the wind, snap out other issues . If he makes the first, he's got the confidence and will likely make the second anyhow.
Icing never really makes sense, but a short field goal would be the only time I can see it having even remote value