1) You lifted this from the Jet fan website 'Turn on the Jets'. At least link to the article.
2) These are not 'outside' evaluations of Geno Smith. They're the evaluations of a bunch of 20-something year old Jets fans who write for a blog. I know the sister of one of the writers you have quoted above. Want to know his football expertise? Zero. Want to know how old he is? 23. He probably also posts here.