Like others, my first reaction was "Who?!". At first, I thought this was a similar situation to the Boar Hunter/Eric Smith back in 2006 when we reached for two players with limited upside. However, after reading more about McDougle there is plenty of upside and I think he was worth the gamble in the 3rd Round.
I definitely said WTF? when we picked this guy. Wasn't familiar with him. I think Idzik realizes that we can't have first round picks at every position. Our secondary value is very well set up with first round picks in Milliner and Pryor. Now we have two lower round picks that could develop nicely.