Results 1 to 4 of 4

Thread: Germans and Russians

  1. #1
    Hall Of Fame
    Join Date
    Apr 2003
    I'd like everybody to read this article, and then post their thoughts.

    [b]Atrocity museum angers Russians
    Kremlin accuses Germans of 'making us look like Nazis'[/b]

    Ian Traynor
    Sunday December 23, 2001
    The Observer

    In the flat countryside north of Berlin, a decaying triangular complex of wooden huts and barracks remains a chilling symbol of Hitler's killing machine.

    Opened in 1934, the Sachsenhausen concentration camp became the SS headquarters for running the elaborate camp network in which millions were to die. It was here that 'medical experiments' were conducted on human guinea pigs, that mass killing was refined using gas chambers before the Nazis practised 'industrial murder' on a vast scale.

    Yet Sachsenhausen also harbours a more obscure, more recent history as the lynchpin of Stalin's gulag in Europe. Mass graves discovered on the site in the former East Germany a decade ago, after the fall of the Berlin Wall, contained the corpses of hundreds of victims not of the Nazis, but of the NKVD, Stalin's secret police.

    A museum just opened on the fringe of the complex sheds light on the little-known story of the NKVD takeover of the camp after Hitler's defeat. This exercise in historical recovery is angering the Kremlin by highlighting Russia's reluctance to face up to the crimes perpetrated in its name, particularly anything that sullies its great triumph over Nazi Germany.

    'This is an attempt to diminish the crimes of the Nazis, to compare the Nazi and the Soviet regimes,' protests Mark Kilevich, a Russian who survived the Nazi camp in the Forties and is now vice-president of the Sachsenhausen International Committee. 'This museum puts the victims and their torturers side by side.'

    The idea that the new museum is a German attempt at historical revisionism, equating the Holocaust with the gulag, is vehemently rebuffed by the Germans, but forcefully argued by the Russian government.

    The Russian embassy in Berlin boycotted the opening of the museum earlier this month. The Russian Foreign Ministry spokesman, Aleksandr Yakovenko, attacked the entire concept of a museum devoted to Soviet crimes 'as an attempt to whitewash the crimes of the Nazis. Sachsenhausen testifies to the darkest side of the Nazi genocide, where thousands of our countrymen fell victim,' he said. 'The [museum] organisers aim to equate the crimes of fascism with the actions of the Soviet occupation powers.'

    The German organisers dismiss the accusations as absurd and the result of a misunderstanding.

    Irina Shcherbakova, a Moscow historian who helped with the years of research that led to the Sachsenhausen museum, says the fierce Russian opposition is a 'very ominous sign' of a historical taboo. 'It's like the earlier Soviet demagogy that can only talk of victory in the Second World War. We have lots of black spots concerning Germany and the war. The KGB kept it all secret for years.'

    Sachsenhausen, where Stalin's son Yakov was murdered by the Nazis, was taken over by the NKVD in August 1945. At least 12,000 of the 60,000 people incarcerated there by the Russians died, mainly starving or freezing to death in the bitter winters of 1946 and 1947.

    The detainees included thousands of junior Nazi officials subjected to rough Russian justice. Many, however, were innocent - including victims of denunciations, large numbers of emigrès who fled Russia to Berlin during or after the revolution, anti-communists, German social democrats and teenagers groundlessly suspected of being Nazi guerrillas.

    The Russian government says it has now 'rehabilitated' 8,000 German victims of the NKVD from those years. But the barbarism meted out by the Russians in Germany in the early post-war years - revenge for the appalling suffering inflicted on the Soviet Union by the Third Reich - remains largely hidden from contemporary Russians.

    In Berlin at the war's end, it is estimated that up to two million German women were raped, mainly by Soviet soldiers. Talk of this and Sachsenhausen is still largely taboo in Russia, where opposition to the museum is reinforced by the fact that most of the 30,000 victims of the Nazis there were Russians.

    Guardian Unlimited © Guardian


  2. #2
    Jets Insider VIP Legend
    Charter JI Member

    Join Date
    May 1999
    While I am no fan of Germany they are one of the few countries that owned up to what they did (though one can argue about wages due to workers used as slaves for German companies in WWII).

    Unlike the Japs or Russians (both of whom did some pretty terrible things) the Germans have kept remnants of concentration camps around as reminders and in many ways have tried to make ammends.

    That said I see nothing wrong with the museum, especially if you know the history of what the Russians did as they raped and pillaged their way into Berlin (they were some pretty pissed off people).

  3. #3
    Maybe the Poles should set up a similar memorial at the Katyn Forest.
    I have no problem with this museum.
    The Russians want to portray themselves as the glorious liberators of Eastern Europe despite the fact their tactics were just as bad as the Nazis. And they'd rather hush it up.

  4. #4
    Hall Of Fame
    Join Date
    Apr 2003
    The point:

    when the shoe was on the other foot, the Germans showed no mercy. For the Russians to overcome them, and beat them, they had to beat them into complete submission with ruthlessness.

    The Russians raped 2 million women.

    The USA dropped two atomic bombs.

    You can't beat bastards down, being nice, or politically correct, who think it is their will to subjugate the planet.

    There is a lesson to be learned here, isn't there? Concerning the Islamo-fascism?

    You have to fight fire with fire.

    I think of Col. Kurtz in Apocolypse Now, describing the the innoculated arms in a pile, his admiration for the Viet Cong...


Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts

Follow Us