you make the call
Both. He is a legendary athlete and one of the greatest players who ever lived, but he also used some form of performance enhancers, without a doubt in my mind. Steroids doesn't make you a hitter who has the keen ability to see what a pitch is just as it leaves the hand, however. He is a legendary player who cheated to hit for more power, and would have been a Hall of Famer with or without roids.